228 Flatbush Ave BK, NY 11217
10am-7pm 7 days a week
Delivery is available to eligible ZIP codes. Check your ZIP and rate at checkout.
-
228 Flatbush Ave BK, NY 11217 -
10am-7pm 7 days a week
Plymouth Cheddars
$15.00 - $17.00
Plymouth Cheddar is America's oldest cheddar. Founded in 1890, The Plymouth Cheese Factory is the second oldest cheesemaking operation in the United States, founded by John Coolidge, the father of President Calvin Coolidge.
Plymouth Original - Aged for one year, an old-world recipe said to be closest to what the settlers of the 1600s enjoyed. As the great forebearer of the whole Plymouth line, this raw heritage cheddar literally tastes like a walk back in time. Also one of Oprah's Favorite Things!
Plymouth Truffle - Aged for sixty days, infused with real truffle morsels from Italy and touches of white truffle oil. Italian black summer truffles, called scorzone, grow naturally and elusively below the soil’s surface in woodlands, and are known to have a subtler flavor than the winter variety. The result here is a luscious slow-dance of flavors; a mellow and approachable cheese that is at once earthy, straightforward, sexy and smooth.
8oz waxed pieces.
Nationwide Shipping
We ship select items nationwide from Brooklyn, NY. We are unable to ship to P.O. Boxes.
Orders ship Monday–Wednesday. At checkout, select an available ship date—the date your order leaves BKLYN Larder, not its arrival date.
Standard Shipping — $25; Two-Day Shipping — $55; Overnight Shipping — $95.
Shipping is charged once per order, no matter how many items you buy. Cheese Club subscriptions ship free. To ship to multiple addresses, please contact us.
Cheese Club subscriptions ship on the third Monday of each month.
Transit times are estimates and depend on your destination and shipping service. Please arrange prompt receipt and refrigeration of perishable deliveries.
For damaged or incorrect items, email mailorder@bklynlarder.com with photos. See our Shipping & Local Delivery Policy for details.
Local Pickup + Delivery
Available from BKLYN Larder
228 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
All orders require at least 24 hours' preparation time, with additional lead time for select items.
You'll see available shipping, delivery, and pick-up times at checkout based on the items in your cart.
Earliest available dates are automatically adjusted based on your order.
Pick-Up Hours:
10am - 7pm, Daily
Local Delivery:
Brooklyn and Queens delivery rates apply to eligible ZIP codes within approximately seven miles of 228 Flatbush Avenue, Brooklyn. Eligible delivery ZIP codes outside that radius use Manhattan delivery rates, including addresses in Brooklyn or Queens. Enter your ZIP code to check availability, then view your delivery rate based on your location and order dollar value on the next checkout screen. We do not offer special delivery arrangements outside our service area. Selected items are available for nationwide shipping.
