Plymouth Cheddars - BKLYN Larder Cheese & Provisions | Artisanal Cheeses | Custom Food Gifts | Gourmet Groceries

Plymouth Cheddars

Plymouth Cheddar is America's oldest cheddar. Founded in 1890, The Plymouth Cheese Factory is the second oldest cheesemaking operation in the United States, founded by John Coolidge, the father of President Calvin Coolidge.

Plymouth Original - Aged for one year, an old-world recipe said to be closest to what the settlers of the 1600s enjoyed. As the great forebearer of the whole Plymouth line, this raw heritage cheddar literally tastes like a walk back in time. Also one of Oprah's Favorite Things!

Plymouth Truffle - Aged for sixty days, infused with real truffle morsels from Italy and touches of white truffle oil. Italian black summer truffles, called scorzone, grow naturally and elusively below the soil’s surface in woodlands, and are known to have a subtler flavor than the winter variety. The result here is a luscious slow-dance of flavors; a mellow and approachable cheese that is at once earthy, straightforward, sexy and smooth. 

8oz waxed pieces.

Nationwide Shipping

This section applies to Shipping orders only.

We ship nationwide via FedEx via Ground or 2 Day Express. Shipping is free for subscriptions and orders $95+. All others ship for a flat $25 rate.

You may select Mon–Thurs ship dates at checkout; we may limit days as needed to protect perishables. Please note: you are choosing the ship date, not the arrival date.

For any damaged or incorrect items, please email mailorder@bklynlarder.com with photos.

See our full Shipping Policy for more details.

Local Pickup + Delivery

We offer Local Pick-up, Local Delivery at:

BKLYN Larder: 228 Flatbush Ave. BK, NY 11217

M-S 10AM - 7PM

Variant

Follow Us @bklynlarder